← The Knowledge Project

#126 Nancy Sherman: Soldiers and Stoics

Dec 14, 2021 1h 7m 16 insights
What can we learn from the intersection between the fundamental tenets of Stoicism and military heroism? Author and professor Nancy Sherman uses her extensive experience in both subjects to discuss why there’s much to gain from examining ancient Greek and Roman philosophies and how to use their teachings today. On this episode Sherman explores how to gain control of your emotions, Stoic techniques for decision making, building resilience, the difference between honor and virtue, and much more. Sherman is a Distinguished University Professor and Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University, and she is also the inaugural Distinguished Chair in Ethics at the United States Naval Academy. She has written extensively during her career on the Stoics, and her most recent book is Stoic Wisdom: Ancient Lessons for Modern Resilience. -- Want even more? Members get early access, hand-edited transcripts, member-only episodes, and so much more. Learn more here: https://fs.blog/membership/ Every Sunday our Brain Food newsletter shares timeless insights and ideas that you can use at work and home. Add it to your inbox: https://fs.blog/newsletter/ Follow Shane on Twitter at: https://twitter.com/ShaneAParrish
Actionable Insights

1. Prioritize Inner Virtue Over External Metrics

Remember that external metrics like social media likes or followers are not a true measure of your worth; instead, focus on cultivating your inner virtue and goodness. This helps you avoid being driven by false glory and superficial validation.

2. Distinguish Virtue from External Goods

Understand that true virtue (excellence of character) is always good and sufficient for happiness, while external factors like health or wealth are ‘indifferents’ that are preferred but should not determine your happiness. This perspective reduces perturbation by anchoring well-being in character.

3. Cultivate Rational, Serene Emotions

Aspire to rational desire, cautiousness, and ‘rational exuberance’ by slowing down responses and filtering them through reason. This transforms debilitating emotions into calm, equitable states.

4. Insert Pause for Emotional Control

Monitor your impressions and reactions by inserting a pause between the initial input and your response. This ‘observing ego’ creates space for reason to take control of your emotions.

5. Pre-rehearse Potential Negative Events

Mentally rehearse potential negative events, from minor annoyances to significant losses, to prepare for them in advance. This reduces the likelihood of being blindsided or upended if they occur.

6. Practice Mental Reservation for Adaptability

Cultivate resilience by framing intentions with an ‘if clause’ (e.g., ‘I’ll do X unless Y happens’). This allows you to be nimble and agile, quickly updating plans based on new information.

7. Focus on Controlling Controllables

Recognize the limits of your control, especially concerning the agency of others, and focus your efforts on what you can genuinely influence. This involves giving space to others’ autonomy and not dictating their actions.

8. Maintain Complex, Multi-Faceted View

When making decisions, strive to understand the full picture and all its facets, rather than focusing on isolated impulses. This helps ensure the best course of action prevails by considering complex representations.

9. Practice Cooperative, Open Listening

Engage in cooperative endeavors that prioritize listening over talking, genuinely seeking to understand other perspectives. This openness allows you to uncover new insights and challenge your own cognitive biases.

10. Be Aware of Confirmation Bias

Recognize your inherent tendency to seek out confirming evidence and disregard refuting information. This awareness is crucial for making better decisions and getting closer to reality.

11. Embrace Emotions as Allies

Recognize that emotions are not always detrimental but can be valuable allies, sparking interest, passion, and commitment. Infuse conversations and intellectual endeavors with this ‘juice’ to foster creativity and deeper understanding.

12. Journal for Emotional Reflection

Engage in daily journaling, particularly at the end of the day, to reflect on your reactions and responses to events. This practice helps clarify thinking, make sense of experiences, and identify areas for improvement.

13. Calm the Autonomic System

Actively seek ways to cool down your autonomic system, recognizing that sped-up emotions often stem from an overactive internal state. This helps reduce unreflective responses and promotes emotional regulation.

14. Incorporate Eastern Mindful Practices

Supplement Stoic reflection with Eastern mindful practices, such as using a mantra, to quiet your mind and empty your head. This approach complements discursive reflection by calming the autonomic system and reducing mental chatter.

15. Visualize Distant Groups as Kin

Practice visualizing distant groups or ‘outer circles’ as part of your ‘inner circle’ or kin, fostering a sense of cosmopolitanism and empathy. This helps you understand what others bring to the world and see yourself as a cooperative global citizen.

16. Seek External Perspective for Self-Compassion

When experiencing self-rage, shame, or guilt, open yourself up to the perspective of a trusted loved one or friend to find self-compassion. This external gaze can help you see yourself through a more benevolent lens.